Meta Faces Record €805 Million Privacy Fine in Italy

Italy's data protection authority, Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, has imposed a hefty €805 million (approximately $887 million) fine on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited. The penalty addresses findings that Meta's Facebook app on Android devices accessed users' photo albums without obtaining proper, specific consent.

The Feature in Question: "Photo Recommendations"

The controversial feature, labeled as providing "recommendations from your photo album while browsing Facebook," has been active since 2023. While browsing the social media platform, the feature would scan a user's local photo gallery to select pictures and videos as suggested content for posting.

The core violation, according to regulators, was that Meta implemented this functionality without providing users with a standalone, clear explanation of what data would be accessed and for what purpose. Users were not asked for explicit consent for this specific photo-accessing behavior, leading to the processing of personal photos, videos, and metadata without adequate legal grounds.

Basis of the Fine and Mandatory Actions

The Italian authority determined the substantial fine based on several key factors:

  • Scale of Impact: A vast number of users were affected.
  • Company Cooperation Meta's level of cooperation during the investigation was deemed insufficient.
  • Nature of Infringement: Processing sensitive personal data without transparent information and valid consent.

Beyond the financial penalty, the watchdog issued strict compliance orders. Meta is required within 60 days to:

  • Change the setting of this photo access feature to "off" by default for all users, including those who had previously enabled it.
  • Seek user consent through a dedicated and unambiguous request.
  • Clearly inform users about the feature's purpose, what album access entails, and how to disable it.

A Stark Reminder of GDPR Enforcement

This fine ranks among the largest ever issued under the EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). It serves as a powerful reminder to technology companies operating in Europe that data processing practices—especially concerning sensitive information—must be grounded in transparency, informed consent, and purpose limitation. Practices like default-on settings, bundled permissions, or vague disclosures carry significant regulatory risks.

For users, the case underscores the importance of scrutinizing permission requests from mobile apps and being mindful about granting access to sensitive data like photo libraries.