A New Regulatory Approach: Separating Blockchain Infrastructure from Financial Applications
A recent policy submission to the UK's Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has proposed a fundamental shift in perspective. In its formal response to two FCA consultation papers, the Hyperliquid Policy Center argued that public blockchains should be treated as neutral, foundational technology infrastructure, akin to internet protocols, within the upcoming crypto asset regulatory framework.
Clarifying Liability: Regulation Should Target Service Providers, Not the Underlying Network
The think tank's argument addresses a core ambiguity in current regulatory thinking. The primary goals of regulation—consumer protection and financial stability—are best achieved by clearly assigning responsibility. Therefore, compliance obligations should logically fall on the regulated entities that directly offer specific financial products or services to customers.
In practice, if an FCA-regulated firm operates a payment service built on a public blockchain, that firm is wholly responsible for its service's compliance. The underlying blockchain protocol, the independent validator nodes securing the network, or the developers of the core software should not automatically be deemed 'regulated entities' simply because their technology is utilized by a financial application.
Charting a Clearer Path for Decentralized Protocols
This position holds significant implications for the decentralized finance (DeFi) sector. HPC specifically called for the FCA to provide greater clarity on how its rules apply to decentralized protocols and on-chain services. Many DeFi applications operate autonomously via smart contracts, lacking a traditional centralized operating entity. Imposing regulatory burdens directly on the infrastructure layer could stifle innovation and create complex enforcement challenges.
The proposal essentially advocates for a "layered" regulatory model:
- The Infrastructure Layer: Public blockchains as open, neutral settlement and data layers, treated as technology-agnostic.
- The Application Layer: Entities building specific financial applications on top must be regulated according to the nature of their business.
This distinction seeks to preserve space for genuine decentralized innovation while ensuring consumer-facing financial activities are properly overseen, aiming for a more precise balance between fostering innovation and mitigating risk.